# Court case Ra 2024/04/0424

> DPA BVwG (Austria) issued a court ruling regarding Court case Ra 2024/04/0424 in Jan 2025, concerning Art. 7(3) GDPR.

Canonical: https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17424/court-case-ra-2024-04-0424-court-ruling-austria-2025
Last updated: 2026-10-18

[](https://cookiefines.eu/cookie-enforcement)

€553.20 — costsDPA BVwG16 January 2025Austria

final

ePrivacy

Court Ruling

A court ruled that a media company's cookie banner did not allow users to easily reject cookies. The court found that the reject option was hidden, making it harder for users to refuse consent. This decision emphasizes the need for clear and accessible consent mechanisms.

Payment details and attribution

costs

imposed

€553.20

Attribution and source

Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.

Recorded EUR value: €553.20

[View source](https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=Vwgh&Entscheidungsart=Undefined&Sammlungsnummer=&Index=&SucheNachRechtssatz=True&SucheNachText=True&GZ=Ra2024%252F04%252F0424&VonDatum=&BisDatum=17.02.2025&Norm=&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=9cd2e132-9596-4971-97c5-c62265704f1e&Dokumentnummer=JWT_2024040424_20250116L00)

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

Enforcing jurisdiction

Austria · Geography does not establish applicable law.

Confirmed applicable legislation

- [EU General Data Protection Regulation](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?legal_regime=eu_gdpr)

Privacy topics

- [Cookies & tracking](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?topic=cookies_tracking)

What happened

The court determined that the media company's cookie banner design violated GDPR by making it difficult for users to reject cookies.

Who was affected

Website visitors who encountered the misleading cookie banner and were unable to easily refuse cookie consent.

What the authority found

The court upheld the DPA's order for the media company to redesign its cookie banner to provide an equivalent option to reject cookies in the first layer.

Why this matters

This ruling reinforces the importance of transparent consent practices for online businesses. Companies must ensure that users can easily refuse cookies, aligning with GDPR requirements.

## Key Facts

On 16 January 2025, DPA BVwG (Austria) issued a court ruling regarding Court case Ra 2024/04/0424. Recorded violation categories: pre-ticked consent boxes and reject harder than accept. GDPR provisions cited: Art. 7(3) GDPR.

Recorded legal citations

Automatically processed

[Art. 7(3) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-7-3-gdpr)Art. 7(3) GDPRConditions for valid consent: must be freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous. Consent can be withdrawn at any time.

View original scraped data

Art. 7(3) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

Decision AuthorityVwGH

Reviewed AuthorityBVwG (Austria)

## Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 11 April 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, national law identified.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. [How we check sources](https://cookiefines.eu/about#source-checks)

[Austria enforcement](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/at)[DPA BVwG actions](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/at/bvwg)[All Court case Ra 2024/04/0424 actions](https://cookiefines.eu/companies/court-case-ra-2024-04-0424)

Full Legal Summary

Detailed

= The data subject visited a website operated by a media company (the controller). Upon opening the website a cookie banner showed up. This cookie banner was designed in such a way that a reject button was “hidden” in a second layer. The cookie banner’s first layer presented only an option to accept the cookies or to manage the options. The cookie manage option was presented as a link. When the data subject clicked on the accept button, they also agreed to pre-ticked options, visible only within the cookie management link. The reject button was a part of the second layer of the cookie banner (within the cookie management link). The data subject lodged a complaint with the Austrian DPA (DSB), claiming the controller violated, inter alia, Article 5(1)(a) GDPR and Article 6(1)(a) GDPR. The data subject was represented by noyb. The controller argued to the DPA that the website provided access to online newspaper articles. Because of that, the processing activities were carried for journalistic purposes and the DPA was not competent to hear the case. The DPA eventually issued a decision, ordering the controller to modify the cookie banner so that its first layer offered an option to close the cookie banner without giving consent. This option had to be visually equivalent to the accept button. The DPA rejected the applications of the data subject regarding the deletion of its data, an order to stop unlawful processing and establishing the violation of data confidentiality (“Recht auf Geheimhaltung”) following from Section 1 of the \[https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/eli/bgbl/i/1999/165/A1P1/NOR40139563 Austrian Data Protection Act (Datenschutzgesetz - DSG)\]. = The controller appealed the DPA’s order to introduce an equivalent reject option in the first layer of its cookie banner to the Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht – BVwG). The Federal Administrative Court dismissed the appeal by the controller. That court held, that the controller’s processing activities didn’t fall within the scope of journalistic purposes. The court emphasised that the controller placed the cookies and processed the collected data for analytical and advertising purposes. Regarding the need for an equivalent reject option in cookie banners the court upheld the interpretation of the DPA that the first layer of the cookie banner needs to contain a visually equivalent option to reject cookies. = The controller appealed the BVwG's decision. In this appeal, the controller stated, that there is a lack of case law on the media privilege and on the design of cookie banners. The controller argued, that the Supreme Administrative Court (Verwaltungsgerichtshof - VwGH) had not yet dealt with this in substance and that thus clarification by it was required. Regarding the design of the cookie banner the court found that Article 7(3) GDPR requires an individual case-by-case examination whether refusing consent is as simple as granting it. The court held that an appeal can only be justified in cases of a blatant misassessment of the individual case-related circumstances by the first instance court. The court did not find this in the present case, stating that the reasoning of the first instance court was detailed and comprehensible. Regarding the media privilege the court held, that the appeal did not indicate which specific legal question the court would have to answer in this context.

Show full summaryHide summary

## Outcome

Court Ruling

A ruling by a national court on a data-protection matter.

## Violations (2)

Reject Harder Than Accept

critical

Refusing cookies requires more clicks or steps than accepting them, or the reject option is less visually prominent.

Pre-ticked Consent Boxes

high

Cookie consent checkboxes are pre-selected by default, violating the requirement for active, affirmative consent.

## Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Court case Ra 2024/04/0424 in AT

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

## Similar Cases

Enforcement actions with similar violations

[Otavamedia Oy 2026 ·](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18199/otavamedia-oy-fine-finland-2026)[Österreichischer Rundfunk - ORF 2026 · Datenschutzbehörde](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17925/osterreichischer-rundfunk-orf-fine-austria-2026)[Online streaming platform (pseudonymised) 2025 · Datenschutzbehörde](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17812/online-streaming-platform-pseudonymised-fine-austria-2025)[Court case 10 A 5385/22 2025 · DPA VGHannover](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17469/court-case-10-a-5385-22-fine-germany-2025)[Court case W252 2282050-1/12E 2024 · Datenschutzbehörde](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17379/court-case-w252-2282050-1-12e-fine-austria-2024)

## Details

Ruling Date

16 January 2025

Authority

DPA BVwG

GDPRhub ID

[gdprhub-court-8957](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=8957)

## Sources

[](https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=Vwgh&Entscheidungsart=Undefined&Sammlungsnummer=&Index=&SucheNachRechtssatz=True&SucheNachText=True&GZ=Ra2024%252F04%252F0424&VonDatum=&BisDatum=17.02.2025&Norm=&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=9cd2e132-9596-4971-97c5-c62265704f1e&Dokumentnummer=JWT_2024040424_20250116L00)[](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=8957)

## About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)

Licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)

Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. *Court case Ra 2024/04/0424 - Austria (2025)*. Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

[Report Inaccuracy](mailto:info@cookiefines.eu?subject=Inaccuracy%20Report:%20Court%20case%20Ra%202024%2F04%2F0424%20%28ID%2017424%29&body=Action%20ID:%2017424%0ACompany:%20Court%20case%20Ra%202024%2F04%2F0424%0APage:%20https%3A%2F%2Fcookiefines.eu%2Factions%2F17424%2Fcourt-case-ra-2024-04-0424-court-ruling-austria-2025%0A%0APlease%20describe%20the%20inaccuracy:%0A)

Last updated: 18 October 2026

## Related

- [About and methodology](https://cookiefines.eu/about)
- [All enforcement actions](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)
