# Court case 10 A 5385/22

> DPA VGHannover (Germany) issued a court ruling regarding Court case 10 A 5385/22 in Mar 2025, concerning Art. 7 GDPR and Art. 6(1) GDPR and Art. 6(1)(a)…

Canonical: https://cookiefines.eu/actions/17469/court-case-10-a-5385-22-court-ruling-germany-2025
Last updated: 2026-11-05

[](https://cookiefines.eu/cookie-enforcement)

Court Ruling

DPA VGHannover19 March 2025Germany

final

ePrivacy

Court Ruling

A German court ruled that a publishing house's cookie consent banner did not meet legal requirements. The court found that users were not given clear options to refuse consent, violating data protection rules. This decision highlights the importance of transparent consent mechanisms for website operators.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

Enforcing jurisdiction

Germany · Geography does not establish applicable law.

Confirmed applicable legislation

- [EU General Data Protection Regulation](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?legal_regime=eu_gdpr)

Privacy topics

- [Cookies & tracking](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?topic=cookies_tracking)

What happened

The court ruled that the publishing house's cookie consent banner failed to provide effective consent for using tracking technologies.

Who was affected

Website visitors who encountered the publishing house's cookie banner on its site.

What the authority found

The court decided that the consent obtained was not valid under GDPR, as it lacked clarity and transparency.

Why this matters

This ruling emphasizes that companies must ensure their consent mechanisms are clear and user-friendly. Website operators should review their cookie banners to avoid similar legal issues.

## Key Facts

On 19 March 2025, DPA VGHannover (Germany) issued a court ruling regarding Court case 10 A 5385/22. Recorded violation categories: reject harder than accept and third-party cookies without consent. GDPR provisions cited: Art. 7 GDPR, Art. 6(1) GDPR, Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR, Art. 4(11) GDPR, Art. 58(2)(d) GDPR. National provisions cited: NDSG, TTDSG.

Recorded legal citations

Automatically processed

[Art. 7 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-7-gdpr)Art. 7 GDPRConditions for valid consent: must be freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous. Consent can be withdrawn at any time.[Art. 6(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-gdpr)Art. 6(1) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-a-gdpr)Art. 6(1)(a) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 4(11) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-4-11-gdpr)[Art. 58(2)(d) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-58-2-d-gdpr)Art. 58(2)(d) GDPRPowers of supervisory authorities: investigative, corrective, and advisory powers of data protection authorities.

View original scraped data

Art. 4(11) GDPR

Art. 6(1) GDPR

Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR

Art. 7(GDPR)

Art. 58(2)(d) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

National Law Articles

AI-identified

NDSG

TTDSG

Decision AuthorityVG Hannover

## Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 12 April 2026.

Processing notes: national law identified.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. [How we check sources](https://cookiefines.eu/about#source-checks)

[Germany enforcement](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/de)[DPA VGHannover actions](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/de/vghannover)[All Court case 10 A 5385/22 actions](https://cookiefines.eu/companies/court-case-10-a-5385-22)

Full Legal Summary

Detailed

The controller is a publishing house that publishes newspapers and content on the Internet at www.noz.de. The controller uses a consent banner (so-called cookie wall) on its website. The defendant is the DPA of Lower Saxony (LfDI). In 15 November 2022, the DPA carried out a technical test on the controller’s website and found that when it was first accessed, without prior consent, the US service Google Tag Manager was contacted meaning that user data were transmitted to Google’s US server and data were stored on the user's device. Also, a consent banner titled "optimal user experience" appeared with the options to "Accept all", in the middle of the banner, or "Accept & close x", at the top right (the x referring to the symbol used to close a window). In order to refuse consent users had to scroll down, select the "Settings" button and at the window opened on a second level, the user must check whether the opt-in controls are switched off in order to then select the "Save selection" button. On 23 November 2022, the DPA issued a decision ordering the controller; a. To implement the requirements for effective consent in accordance with Article 4(11) and Article 7 GDPR, insofar as this is necessary for the lawfulness of the use of local storage objects, tracking technologies and third-party services; b. To obtain effective consent for the Google Tag Manager service integrated in the website in accordance with Section 25 (1) of the german Telecommunications-Digital Services Data Protection Act (TTDSG) and Art. 6(1) (a) GDPR or to remove the service; and c. To comply with the orders within 1 month. The DPA argued that the consent was not fully informed and voluntary in accordance with Article 4(11) GDPR. At the first level of the banner there was no literal mention that the buttons "Accept all" and "Accept & close x" provide two options for granting consent and also there was no option to refuse consent. On December 2022, the controller filed a case before Administrative Court of Hanover (Verwaltungsgericht Hannover - VG Hannover) requesting the annulment of the DPA’s order. They argued that the DPA is not responsible for issuing such order, that the controller does not process any personal data, that user’s consent was obtained lawfully and that they process the data to fulfill a legal obligation pursuant to Article 6(1)(c) GDPR. The DPA responded that the legal basis for the order can be found in Article 58(2)(d) GDPR and § 20 para. 1 of the Lower Saxony Data Protection Act (NDSG). First, the court held that the controller processes personal data within the meaning of Article 4(1) GDPR. Cookies stored on end devices that contain IP addresses and individual user’s IDs, as online identifiers, are considered personal data. Second, the court found that the order under point (a) is materially lawful. The use of cookies and other technologies on the controller's website violates Section 25(1) TTDSG and Article 6(1) GDPR. The setting of these cookies to user’s devices requires effective consent that meets the requirements of Article 4(11) GDPR. The controller’s cookie banner does not meet these requirements because; 1. At the first level the number of the third-party service providers is missing. 2. At the first level the user must scroll down in order to reach the Settings button that gives the possibility to withdraw consent. 3. The overall view of the design of the various levels of the consent banner shows that users are to be specifically directed towards a declaration of consent and their right to choose is to be influenced. 4. The "Accept & close x" button at the top right, is considered non-transparent and surprising design and cannot be assumed that a legally relevant, conscious consent is given. 5. There was no literal mention of “consent”. Furthermore, the processing of personal data by the controller is not carried out to fulfill a legal obligation. Third, it held that the order under point (b) is also lawful. The controller is in breach of Section 25 (1) TTDSG and Article 6(1) GDPR for using the Google Tag Manager service itself without obtaining prior consent from users and that this data processing is also not justified under any legal basis Article 6(1) GDPR. c. Fourth, the order under point (c) is also lawful under Article 58(2)(d) GDPR. Lastly, the court decided that the case is unfounded.

Show full summaryHide summary

## Outcome

Decision

On 19 March 2025, the Administrative Court of Hanover dismissed the publisher’s challenge to the data protection authority’s order concerning the consent banner and Google Tag Manager. The publisher must bear court costs and the authority’s procedural costs; the judgment does not quantify either amount or impose a fine. Any later appeal, separate cost assessment and payment have not been independently verified.

## Violations (2)

Reject Harder Than Accept

critical

Refusing cookies requires more clicks or steps than accepting them, or the reject option is less visually prominent.

Third-Party Cookies Without Consent

critical

Third-party tracking cookies or scripts are loaded without obtaining prior user consent.

## Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Court case 10 A 5385/22 in DE

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

## Similar Cases

Enforcement actions with similar violations

[DPA case Takeaway B.V. - z2022-04011 2024 · Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/19116/dpa-case-takeaway-b-v-z2022-04011-fine-netherlands-2024)[DPA case 9782890 2022 · Garante per la protezione dei dati personali](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18835/dpa-case-9782890-fine-italy-2022)[DPA case 9788429 2022 · Garante per la protezione dei dati personali](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18828/dpa-case-9788429-fine-italy-2022)[DPA case 11/2022 2022 · Autorité de Protection des Données](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18807/dpa-case-11-2022-fine-belgium-2022)[DPA case ZSPR.440.331.2019.PR.PAM 2021 · Urząd Ochrony Danych Osobowych](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18778/dpa-case-zspr-440-331-2019-pr-pam-fine-poland-2021)

## Details

Ruling Date

19 March 2025

Authority

DPA VGHannover

GDPRhub ID

[gdprhub-court-9298](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=9298)

## Sources

[](https://voris.wolterskluwer-online.de/browse/document/230df5cf-d76c-4561-9499-e44445a96f11)[](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=9298)

## About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)

Licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)

Cite as: Cookie Fines. *Court case 10 A 5385/22 - Germany (2025)*. Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

[Report Inaccuracy](mailto:info@cookiefines.eu?subject=Inaccuracy%20Report:%20Court%20case%2010%20A%205385%2F22%20%28ID%2017469%29&body=Action%20ID:%2017469%0ACompany:%20Court%20case%2010%20A%205385%2F22%0APage:%20https%3A%2F%2Fcookiefines.eu%2Factions%2F17469%2Fcourt-case-10-a-5385-22-court-ruling-germany-2025%0A%0APlease%20describe%20the%20inaccuracy:%0A)

Last updated: 5 November 2026

## Related

- [About and methodology](https://cookiefines.eu/about)
- [All enforcement actions](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)
