# Court case W256 2227693-1

> Datenschutzbehörde (Austria) issued a court ruling regarding Court case W256 2227693-1 in Sept 2023, concerning Art. 7 GDPR and Art. 13 GDPR and Art. 17…

Canonical: https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18063/court-case-w256-2227693-1-court-ruling-austria-2023
Last updated: 2026-11-05

[](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)

Court Ruling

Datenschutzbehörde28 September 2023Austria

final

Court Ruling

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

An Austrian court ruled that a customer loyalty program's consent process was not clear enough for profiling users. The data protection authority had found that the consent declaration did not meet legal requirements. This decision shows that companies must ensure their consent processes are transparent and understandable.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

Enforcing jurisdiction

Austria · Geography does not establish applicable law.

Confirmed applicable legislation

- [EU General Data Protection Regulation](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?legal_regime=eu_gdpr)

Privacy topics

- [Data subject rights](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?topic=data_subject_rights)

What happened

The court found that the consent process for profiling in a customer loyalty program was not compliant with GDPR.

Who was affected

Users of the customer loyalty program whose data was processed for profiling without clear consent.

What the authority found

The court determined that the data protection authority's decision was justified, as the consent declaration lacked clarity and transparency.

Why this matters

This ruling underscores the importance of clear and intelligible consent processes for companies. It serves as a reminder that vague consent declarations can lead to legal challenges.

## Key Facts

On 28 September 2023, Datenschutzbehörde (Austria) issued a court ruling regarding Court case W256 2227693-1. GDPR provisions cited: Art. 7 GDPR, Art. 13 GDPR, Art. 17 GDPR, Art. 21 GDPR, Art. 22 GDPR, Art. 4(4) GDPR, Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR, Art. 58 GDPR, Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR, Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR, Art. 6(4) GDPR, Art. 58(2)(f) GDPR. National provisions cited: Article 133(4) B-VG.

Recorded legal citations

Automatically processed

[Art. 7 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-7-gdpr)Art. 7 GDPRConditions for valid consent: must be freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous. Consent can be withdrawn at any time.[Art. 13 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-13-gdpr)Art. 13 GDPRInformation to provide when collecting data directly from the person (identity of controller, purpose, legal basis, retention period, rights).[Art. 17 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-17-gdpr)Art. 17 GDPRRight to erasure ('right to be forgotten'): people can request deletion of their personal data in certain circumstances.[Art. 21 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-21-gdpr)Art. 21 GDPRRight to object: people can object to processing based on legitimate interests or for direct marketing purposes.[Art. 22 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-22-gdpr)Art. 22 GDPRAutomated decision-making and profiling: people have the right not to be subject to decisions made solely by automated means that significantly affect them.[Art. 4(4) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-4-4-gdpr)[Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-5-1-a-gdpr)Art. 5(1)(a) GDPRCore data protection principles: lawfulness, fairness, transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation, integrity, and accountability.[Art. 58 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-58-gdpr)Art. 58 GDPRPowers of supervisory authorities: investigative, corrective, and advisory powers of data protection authorities.[Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-a-gdpr)Art. 6(1)(a) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-f-gdpr)Art. 6(1)(f) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 6(4) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-4-gdpr)Art. 6(4) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 58(2)(f) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-58-2-f-gdpr)Art. 58(2)(f) GDPRPowers of supervisory authorities: investigative, corrective, and advisory powers of data protection authorities.

View original scraped data

Art. 4(4) GDPR

Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR

Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR

Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR

Art. 6(4) GDPR

Art. 7(GDPR)

Art. 13(GDPR)

Art. 17(GDPR)

Art. 21(GDPR)

Art. 22(GDPR)

Art. 58(GDPR)

Art. 58(2)(f) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

National Law Articles

AI-identified

Article 133(4) B-VG

Decision AuthorityBVwG

Reviewed AuthorityDSB (Austria)

## Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 18 July 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, national law identified, authority corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. [How we check sources](https://cookiefines.eu/about#source-checks)

[Austria enforcement](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/at)[Datenschutzbehörde actions](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/at/dsb)[All Court case W256 2227693-1 actions](https://cookiefines.eu/companies/court-case-w256-2227693-1)

Full Legal Summary

Detailed

On 05.09.2019, the Austrian DPA (DSB) notified the controller of a customer loyalty program that they were initiating an ex officio investigation. The controller responded by answering the provided questionnaire and submitting further documents. On 23.10.2019, the DPA ruled that the investigation was justified and that the declaration of consent for profiling using certain registration methods (website, app, partner company store, flyer) did not comply with the requirements of Article 4(11) GDPR and Article 7 GDPR, nor were they provided in an intelligible way. If a contract covers several aspects, the declaration of consent must be clearly distinguishable. Regarding the website and flyer, the following was found: The website says 'Enjoy your personal benefits' without providing clear information that 'personal benefits' involves profiling. In an embedded box, the relevant points were merely referred to. Information regarding profiling was only accessible by scrolling down further. Concerning the flyer, the following information was provided under the signature field: 'This signature only applies to the declaration of consent and is voluntary. Your registration \[...\] is also valid without a signature.' Thus, it conveyed the impression that a signature was required to confirm the registration. Consequently, the controller was required to amend the declaration and to cease using any obtained consents for the purpose of profiling prior to 01.05.2020. The controller lodged a complaint. In addition to other information, the controller stated that the data processing was in accordance with Article 6(1)(a) GDPR, and that they had a legitimate interest under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR. The DPA ruled a preliminary decision on the complaint, thereby changing the ruling that the website and flyer did not meet the requirements under Article 6(1)(a) GDPR, and thus, the processing of personal data, collected in that cases, was forbidden. The other methods ensured that the consent was clearly separated from the rest of the registration process. The controller then filed a request for referral to the court, arguing that the DPA had exceeded their corrective powers by prohibiting the processing of the data. Furthermore, the data processing for profiling would be used to manage customer memberships under Article 6(1)(b) GDPR. Following their view, processing under Article 6(4) GDPR was applicable. Additionally, the controller denied the DPA's view that a violation of the principle of good faith would foreclose a weighing of interests under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR. The court quashed the preliminary decision as the DPA had not examined the other grounds of justification for data processing under Article 6(1) GDPR in their initial decision. The DPA then lodged an appeal to the Austrian Supreme Administrative Court (Verwaltungsgerichtshof), which overturned the court's ruling (\[https://ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?ResultFunctionToken=844801d7-ae74-4038-8071-841905f3f78f&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=True&Abfrage=Vwgh&Entscheidungsart=Undefined&Sammlungsnummer=&Index=&SucheNachRechtssatz=True&SucheNachText=True&GZ=Ro+2021%2f04%2f0033&VonDatum=&BisDatum=17.07.2026&Norm=&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Dokumentnummer=JWT\_2021040033\_20220208J00 VwGH 08.02.2022, Ro 2021/04/0033\]). It was the court's responsibility to examine the potential legal bases, rather than overturning the DPA's decision. Therefore, the case was returned to the court. In the meantime, the controller complied with the preliminary decision by deleting the affected personal data in 2021 and changing their registration process in 2020. First, the court found that they had to formally rule on whether the DPA's decision was lawful at the time it was ruled. It is not to be considered that the controller complied with the administrative decision and fulfilled the required steps (\[https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=Vwgh&GZ=Ra+2022%2f06%2f0056&SkipToDocumentPage=True&SucheNachRechtssatz=False&SucheNachText=True&ResultFunctionToken=c2bc8e93-e95d-4a66-b3b8-643a4325eae3&Dokumentnummer=JWT\_2022060056\_20220428L00 VwGH 28.04.2022, Ra 2022/06/0056\]). Second, the court held that the controller did not comply with the transparency requirements regarding the layout of their declaration of consent under Article 7(2) GDPR in both cases (website, flyer). Third, the court ruled that they could not agree with DPA's view, that an invalid declaration of consent always constitutes unlawful data processing and that a review of other grounds of justification would not be necessary (\[https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62021CJ0252 CLEU in 'Meta Platforms and Others' (C-252/21) ECLI:EU:C:2023:537\]). Further on, the Supreme Administrative Court ruled that both, the DPA and the court are required to examine the presence of other grounds (\[https://ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?ResultFunctionToken=844801d7-ae74-4038-8071-841905f3f78f&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=True&Abfrage=Vwgh&Entscheidungsart=Undefined&Sammlungsnummer=&Index=&SucheNachRechtssatz=True&SucheNachText=True&GZ=Ro+2021%2f04%2f0033&VonDatum=&BisDatum=17.07.2026&Norm=&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Dokumentnummer=JWT\_2021040033\_20220208J00 VwGH 08.02.2022, Ro 2021/04/0033\]). Fourth, the court held that the controller could not base their appeal on Article 6(4) GDPR as the data processing did not satisfy the grounds of justification, nor were other grounds apparent. Inter alia, following the CLEU's preliminary ruling in \[https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62021CJ0252 'Meta Platforms and Others' (C-252/21) ECLI:EU:C:2023:537\], three cumulative requirements must be met for data processing under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR: (1) The controller or a third party must have a legitimate interest, (2) which requires the processing of that personal data, (3) and 'the fundamental rights and freedoms of the data subject' must not outweigh those interests. There were no doubts about the controller's legitimate interest in processing the personal data in question for targeted marketing purposes, as this was both necessary and reasonable. However, the data subject should have been notified about profiling. The wording 'only if the member consents' did not constitute such a notification, and therefore the data subjects were not to be expected that their personal data was used for profiling purposes. Furthermore, the controller explicitly excluded it in their general terms and conditions. Hence, the data subject's right to secrecy overrode the controller's legitimate interest. In summary, the court dismissed the controller's complaint. Last, the court held that an appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court was admissible under \[https://ris.bka.gv.at/eli/bgbl/1930/1/A133/NOR40201324?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=B-VG&Gesetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=133&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=17.07.2026&VonInkrafttretedatum=&BisInkrafttretedatum=&VonAusserkrafttretedatum=&BisAusserkrafttretedatum=&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=6de721aa-e72c-4f30-ab00-f9dcd1f2f196 Article 133(4) B-VG\], as no prevailing case law concerning the implementation of a declaration of consent existed. Hence, the decision relied on a legal question of fundamental importance.

Show full summaryHide summary

## Outcome

Decision

In judgment W256 2227693-1 of 28 September 2023, the Austrian Federal Administrative Court dismissed the appeal and clarified the limited prohibition on specified customer profiling. On 29 September 2025, the Administrative Court rejected the further revision and ordered the appellant to reimburse EUR 553.20 in costs to the state. Those costs are recorded once with the separate court record Ro 2023/04/0045; they are not a fine. The original authority decision has not been independently verified.

## Related Cases (1)

Other cases involving Court case W256 2227693-1 in AT

[Court Ruling Aug 2021· Datenschutzbehörde The appellant is a company which ran a loyalty programme for which it collected and processed data subjects’ personal data. More precisely, it “combin...](https://cookiefines.eu/actions/5162/court-case-w256-2227693-1-court-ruling-austria-2021)

Current

Sept 2023

Court Ruling

## Details

Ruling Date

28 September 2023

Authority

Datenschutzbehörde

GDPRhub ID

[gdprhub-court-4468](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=4468)

## Sources

[](https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?ResultFunctionToken=14be1de6-dc2c-4c6c-83ff-d8ffa9e72eb5&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=True&Abfrage=Bvwg&Entscheidungsart=Undefined&SucheNachRechtssatz=True&SucheNachText=True&GZ=&VonDatum=01.01.2014&BisDatum=&Norm=DSGVO&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=EinerWoche&ImRisSeitForRemotion=EinerWoche&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Dokumentnummer=BVWGT_20230928_W256_2227693_1_00)[](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=4468)

## About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)

Licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)

Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. *Court case W256 2227693-1 - Austria (2023)*. Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

[Report Inaccuracy](mailto:info@cookiefines.eu?subject=Inaccuracy%20Report:%20Court%20case%20W256%202227693-1%20%28ID%2018063%29&body=Action%20ID:%2018063%0ACompany:%20Court%20case%20W256%202227693-1%0APage:%20https%3A%2F%2Fcookiefines.eu%2Factions%2F18063%2Fcourt-case-w256-2227693-1-court-ruling-austria-2023%0A%0APlease%20describe%20the%20inaccuracy:%0A)

Last updated: 5 November 2026

## Related

- [About and methodology](https://cookiefines.eu/about)
- [All enforcement actions](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)
