# Court case 10 A 5144/23

> DPA VGHannover (Germany) records an imposed fine of €8,000 involving Court case 10 A 5144/23 in Aug 2026, concerning Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR and Art. 5(1)(e) …

Canonical: https://cookiefines.eu/actions/18231/court-case-10-a-5144-23-court-ruling-germany-2026
Last updated: 2026-11-05

[](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)

€8KDPA VGHannover7 August 2026Germany

final

Court Ruling

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

A German court upheld a reprimand against a doner kebab production facility for extensive employee surveillance. The court found that the facility violated GDPR principles by not having a valid legal basis for the monitoring. This case serves as a warning for businesses about the legal limits of employee surveillance.

Payment details and attribution

costs

unknown

€1,000

Attribution and source

Not included in attributed totals for this payment status.

Recorded EUR value: €1,000

[View source](https://voris.wolterskluwer-online.de/browse/document/51d73757-b5ba-4bab-bcff-56b9010e2129)

fine

imposed

€8,000

Attribution and source

Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.

Recorded EUR value: €8,000

[View source](https://voris.wolterskluwer-online.de/browse/document/51d73757-b5ba-4bab-bcff-56b9010e2129)

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

Enforcing jurisdiction

Germany · Geography does not establish applicable law.

Confirmed applicable legislation

- [EU General Data Protection Regulation](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?legal_regime=eu_gdpr)

Privacy topics

- [Lawfulness & transparency](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?topic=lawfulness_transparency)

What happened

A doner kebab production facility was reprimanded for installing video cameras to monitor employees without proper justification.

Who was affected

Employees working at the doner kebab production facility.

What the authority found

The court confirmed that the facility violated GDPR rules regarding lawful processing and data storage limitations.

Why this matters

This ruling highlights the need for businesses to carefully assess their surveillance practices and ensure they comply with data protection laws to avoid penalties.

## Key Facts

On 7 August 2026, DPA VGHannover (Germany) records an imposed fine of €8,000 involving Court case 10 A 5144/23. GDPR provisions cited: Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR, Art. 5(1)(e) GDPR, Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR, Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR, Art. 30(1) GDPR.

Recorded legal citations

Automatically processed

[Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-5-1-a-gdpr)Art. 5(1)(a) GDPRCore data protection principles: lawfulness, fairness, transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation, integrity, and accountability.[Art. 5(1)(e) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-5-1-e-gdpr)Art. 5(1)(e) GDPRCore data protection principles: lawfulness, fairness, transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation, integrity, and accountability.[Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-a-gdpr)Art. 6(1)(a) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-f-gdpr)Art. 6(1)(f) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 30(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-30-1-gdpr)

View original scraped data

Art. 5(1)(a) GDPR

Art. 5(1)(e) GDPR

Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR

Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR

Art. 30(1) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

Decision AuthorityVG Hannover

## Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 11 September 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, authority corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. [How we check sources](https://cookiefines.eu/about#source-checks)

[Germany enforcement](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/de)[DPA VGHannover actions](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/de/vghannover)[All Court case 10 A 5144/23 actions](https://cookiefines.eu/companies/court-case-10-a-5144-23)

Full Legal Summary

Detailed

The owner of a doner kebab production facility (the controller) had installed video cameras to monitor virtually every room of the business premises. Cameras were placed in the parking lot, the goods receiving and shipping areas, production area, the office, and staff break rooms. The monitoring of employees (the data subjects) was discovered during a labour inspectorate inspection in June 2022, which informed the DPA. In September 2023, the DPA reprimanded and fined the controller for violations of the principle of lawfulness and storage limitation, lack of legal basis for the processing, and the obligation to maintain a record of processing activities. The DPA issued two separate decisions against the controller – one where it fined the controller, and a separate decision where it issued the controller a reprimand. Upon the controller's appeal regarding the decision issuing the fine, the amount of the fine was reduced to €8,000 by a decision of the Local Court Hannover (Amtsgericht Hannover). The controller appealed the reprimand decision to the Administrative Court Hannover (Verwaltungsgericht Hannover) and argued that the employees had given their consent to the surveillance. It also stated that the surveillance was necessary to ensure compliance with hygiene regulations and that the outdoor areas were monitored to prevent break-ins, theft, and vandalism. According to the controller, both a reprimand and a fine for the same violations infringed the general prohibition against double punishment. The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the reprimand issued to the controller. It held that the controller had violated Articles 5(1)(a), 5(1)(e), 6(1), and 30 GDPR. Moreover, the court stated that issuing a reprimand and a fine for the same GDPR violations did not constitute a double punishment, as a reprimand does not fall under the criminal law definition of a sanction. The court pointed out that a reprimand is an administrative measure that involves a finding of a GDPR violation but does not serve a punitive purpose. Regarding the lawfulness of the processing, the court examined whether consent or legitimate interest could be relied upon. For consent, the court found that the processing could not be based on Article 6(1)(a) GDPR: the controller had not provided any evidence that the employees would have consented to the processing. The controller could not rely on legitimate interests under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR either, as no balancing test had been conducted. In addition, the court pointed out that neither compliance with hygiene regulations nor the prevention of burglaries and vandalism could constitute legitimate interests in the present case. Regarding hygiene, the court pointed out that the controller was required to comply with hygiene provisions by law as a business that processes food of animal origin. There was also no factual evidence for crimes mentioned by the controller being a threat in the area. Furthermore, the court held that the controller had infringed the principle of storage limitation by storing the video surveillance footage for longer than necessary: some data had been stored for years. Finally, the court confirmed that the controller had also violated Article 30(1) GDPR as it had not provided a record of processing activities despite the DPA's repeated requests.

Show full summaryHide summary

## Outcome

Decision

On 7 August 2026 the Hanover Administrative Court dismissed the company’s challenge to a data protection reprimand and an administrative fee of EUR 1,000. It also reported that a separate final judgment of the Hanover Local Court had reduced the related fine to EUR 8,000. The company is anonymised in the reviewed judgment. Any appeal against the administrative judgment, separately assessed court costs and actual payment have not been independently verified.

## Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Court case 10 A 5144/23 in DE

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

## Details

Ruling Date

7 August 2026

Authority

DPA VGHannover

Fine Amount

€8,000

GDPRhub ID

[gdprhub-court-10258](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=10258)

## Sources

[](https://www.juris.de/static/infodienst/autoren/D_NJRE001652159.htm)[](https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?curid=10258)

## About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)

Licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)

Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. *Court case 10 A 5144/23 - Germany (2026)*. Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

[Report Inaccuracy](mailto:info@cookiefines.eu?subject=Inaccuracy%20Report:%20Court%20case%2010%20A%205144%2F23%20%28ID%2018231%29&body=Action%20ID:%2018231%0ACompany:%20Court%20case%2010%20A%205144%2F23%0APage:%20https%3A%2F%2Fcookiefines.eu%2Factions%2F18231%2Fcourt-case-10-a-5144-23-court-ruling-germany-2026%0A%0APlease%20describe%20the%20inaccuracy:%0A)

Last updated: 5 November 2026

## Related

- [About and methodology](https://cookiefines.eu/about)
- [All enforcement actions](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)
