# Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein

> The Court of Justice of the European Union delivered a judgment in a case involving Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein in Dec 2023, concerning Art. 24 GDPR …

Canonical: https://cookiefines.eu/actions/6658/medizinischer-dienst-nordrhein-cjeu-ruling-european-union-2023
Last updated: 2026-11-04

[](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)

CJEU Judgment

Court of Justice of the European Union21 December 2023European Union

final

CJEU Judgment

CJEU judgment — not a DPA enforcement action

This is a Court of Justice ruling, not an enforcement action by a data protection authority. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

After an EU Court ruling on employee health data, Germany’s Federal Labour Court dismissed the employee’s damages claim against Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein.

Jurisdiction and applicable law

Enforcing jurisdiction

European Union · Geography does not establish applicable law.

Confirmed applicable legislation

- [EU General Data Protection Regulation](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?legal_regime=eu_gdpr)

Privacy topics

- [Security & breaches](https://cookiefines.eu/enforcement?topic=security_breach)

What happened

The CJEU addressed the legality of a medical service processing an employee's health data for assessing their work capacity.

Who was affected

The employee whose health data was processed by the medical service.

What the authority found

The employee’s EUR 20,000 compensation request was not awarded; the final court assigned unquantified appeal costs to the employee.

Why this matters

This ruling highlights the complexities of processing sensitive health data in the workplace. Employers must ensure compliance with strict data protection standards when handling such information.

## Key Facts

On 21 December 2023, The Court of Justice of the European Union delivered its judgment in a case involving Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein (reference from European Union). GDPR provisions cited: Art. 24 GDPR, Art. 5(1)(f) GDPR, Art. 6(1) GDPR, Art. 9(1) GDPR, Art. 9(2)(h) GDPR, Art. 9(3) GDPR, Art. 32(1) GDPR, Art. 82(1) GDPR. National provisions cited: Artikel 275 (1) Sozialgesetzbuch, Artikel 2758 (1) Sozialgesetzbuch, 274110.

Recorded legal citations

Automatically processed

[Art. 24 GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-24-gdpr)[Art. 5(1)(f) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-5-1-f-gdpr)Art. 5(1)(f) GDPRCore data protection principles: lawfulness, fairness, transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation, integrity, and accountability.[Art. 6(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-6-1-gdpr)Art. 6(1) GDPRLegal bases for processing personal data (consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task, or legitimate interests).[Art. 9(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-9-1-gdpr)Art. 9(1) GDPRProcessing of sensitive data (health, biometrics, race, religion, politics, sexual orientation, union membership). Generally prohibited unless an exception applies.[Art. 9(2)(h) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-9-2-h-gdpr)Art. 9(2)(h) GDPRProcessing of sensitive data (health, biometrics, race, religion, politics, sexual orientation, union membership). Generally prohibited unless an exception applies.[Art. 9(3) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-9-3-gdpr)Art. 9(3) GDPRProcessing of sensitive data (health, biometrics, race, religion, politics, sexual orientation, union membership). Generally prohibited unless an exception applies.[Art. 32(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-32-1-gdpr)Art. 32(1) GDPRSecurity of processing: organisations must implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to protect personal data.[Art. 82(1) GDPR](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr/art-82-1-gdpr)Art. 82(1) GDPRRight to compensation: anyone who has suffered material or non-material damage due to a GDPR violation has the right to compensation.

View original scraped data

Art. 5(1)(f) GDPR

Art. 6(1) GDPR

Art. 9(1) GDPR

Art. 9(2)(h) GDPR

Art. 9(3) GDPR

Art. 24(GDPR)

Art. 32(1) GDPR

Art. 82(1) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

National Law Articles

AI-identified

Artikel 275 (1) Sozialgesetzbuch

Artikel 2758 (1) Sozialgesetzbuch

274110

Decision AuthorityCJEU

## Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 19 March 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. [How we check sources](https://cookiefines.eu/about#source-checks)

[European Union enforcement](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/eu)[Court of Justice of the European Union actions](https://cookiefines.eu/countries/eu/cjeu)[All Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein actions](https://cookiefines.eu/companies/medizinischer-dienst-nordrhein)

Full Legal Summary

Detailed

The Medical Service of Health Insurance (the controller) is Germany's public health insurance medical review service. It provides expert reports when people say they are unable to work, as well as for its own staff. Before becoming unable to work, the data subject worked for the controller. The insurance company that was paying their benefits requested an expert opinion from the controller. The controller obtained health information from the data subject's doctor in the form of a medical report, which was then distributed to the data subject's coworkers. The data subject believed that their medical data had been unlawfully processed and sought €20,000 in damages from the controller, who rejected the claims. According to the data subject, the evaluation should have been performed by another organisation in order to prevent coworkers from accessing their medical data. Furthermore, they considered the security procedures around their medical report's archiving to be inadequate. After being rejected at first and second (Landesarbeitsgericht Düsseldorf) instance, the the data subject appealed to the Federal Labour Court, who referred the case to the CJEU with the following questions: On the topic of health data 1) Does Article 9(2)(h) GDPR prohibit a medical service of a health insurance fund from processing its employee’s health data when it is a prerequisite for the assessment of that employee’s working capacity? 2) If the Court answers Question 1 in the negative (with the consequence that an exception to the prohibition on the processing of data concerning health laid down in Article 9(1) GDPR is possible under Article 9(2)(h) GDPR) in a case such as the present one, are there further data protection requirements, beyond the conditions set out in Article 9(3) GDPR, that must be complied with, and, if so, which ones? 3) If the Court answers Question 1 in the negative, does the permissibility or lawfulness of the processing of data concerning health depend on the fulf

Show full summaryHide summary

## Outcome

Decision

The Court of Justice answered questions on health-data processing in C-667/21 on 21 December 2023. In the national follow-up, 8 AZR 253/20 of 20 June 2024, Germany’s Federal Labour Court rejected the employee’s appeal against the earlier dismissal of his damages claim. The EUR 20,000 previously requested was not awarded. The employee must bear the costs of the final appeal, but the judgment does not quantify them. A later cost assessment and payment remain unverified.

## Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein in EU

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

## Details

Judgment Date

21 December 2023

Authority

Court of Justice of the European Union

## Sources

[](https://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?docid=280768&doclang=en)[](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62021CJ0667)

## About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)

Licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)

Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. *Medizinischer Dienst Nordrhein - European Union (2023)*. Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

[Report Inaccuracy](mailto:info@cookiefines.eu?subject=Inaccuracy%20Report:%20Medizinischer%20Dienst%20Nordrhein%20%28ID%206658%29&body=Action%20ID:%206658%0ACompany:%20Medizinischer%20Dienst%20Nordrhein%0APage:%20https%3A%2F%2Fcookiefines.eu%2Factions%2F6658%2Fmedizinischer-dienst-nordrhein-cjeu-ruling-european-union-2023%0A%0APlease%20describe%20the%20inaccuracy:%0A)

Last updated: 4 November 2026

## Related

- [About and methodology](https://cookiefines.eu/about)
- [All enforcement actions](https://cookiefines.eu/gdpr-enforcement)
