KSV1870 Information GmbH

€964.82 — costs · +1 more paymentsDPA30 March 2026Austria
pending
Court Ruling

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

A court ruled that KSV1870 Information GmbH unlawfully processed personal data, leading to a customer's contract rejection based on an inaccurate credit score. The court awarded the customer €1,500 for the distress caused. This case shows that companies must ensure accuracy in automated decision-making processes.

Payment details and attribution

costs

imposed

€964.82

Attribution and source

Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.

Recorded EUR value: €964.82

View source

damages

imposed

€1,500

Attribution and source

Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.

Recorded EUR value: €1,500

View source

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
Austria · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation
Privacy topics

What happened

KSV1870 Information GmbH provided an inaccurate credit score that resulted in the automated rejection of a customer's application for an energy supply contract.

Who was affected

An individual whose application for an energy supply contract was rejected due to an inaccurate credit score from KSV1870.

What the authority found

The court found that KSV1870 violated GDPR by failing to inform the customer about automated decision-making and by relying on inaccurate information.

Why this matters

This ruling highlights the importance of transparency and accuracy in automated decision-making. Companies must ensure that customers are informed about such processes and that the data used is correct.

Recorded legal citations
Automatically processed
Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR
Art. 22(1) GDPR
Art. 22(2) GDPR
Art. 22(3) GDPR
View original scraped data
Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR
Art. 22(1) GDPR
Art. 22(2) GDPR
Art. 22(3) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

Decision AuthorityOLG Wien
Reviewed AuthorityLGfZRS Wien (Austria)

Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Review needed — 15 April 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, entity split needed.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

An individual (the data subject) intended to conclude an energy supply contract online with Go Green Energy GmbH (the energy provider). After initially receiving an email accepting the data subject as a customer the data subject's contract was automatically rejected due to an insufficient credit score provided to the energy provider by KSV1870 Information GmbH (the credit information agency or "KSV"). Therefore, the credit information agency's credit score led to the automated rejection of the data subject's application for the energy supply contract. The data subject eventually submitted a request to the energy provider requesting information under GDPR, in particular regarding the data exchanged with KSV. Furthermore, he submitted an access request with KSV under Article 15 GDPR. The data subject considered KSV’s response to his access request to be incomplete and filed a lawsuit claiming damages from KSV as well as the energy provider. The data subject claimed that he never consented to automated decision-making, but that the two controllers subjected him to such decision-making unlawfully in violation of Article 22 GDPR. Moreover, the data subject claim that the controllers relied on inaccurate information to calculate his credit rating, thus breaching the principle of accuracy under Article 5(1)(d) GDPR. The data subject argued that the refusal caused him worry, annoyance and stress, thereby resulting in non-pecuniary damage. He claimed €1,500 from both controllers under Article 82 GDPR in court. KSV claimed that it processed personal data under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR (i.e. legitimate interest) and that all data subjects have the right to request correction of their personal data used for the purpose of credit rating. Moreover, KSV argued that it only provided the energy provider with a credit rating, which was not a sufficient reason for a refusal to enter into a contract, and that it had no control over the energy provider's reasons for refusal. Therefore, KSV considered that their credit scoring could not be considered automated decision making under Article 22 GDPR. The energy provider argued that its automated decision-making was necessary due to the high number of requests for contracts it receives, and that it is permitted under Article 22(2)(a) GDPR. It further claimed that manually verifying every credit rating would be unreasonable, that it did not violate Article 5 GDPR, and that in case a human being would have reviewed the case, it would have reached the same conclusion and the subsequent rejection would have led to the same alleged stress, annoyance and concern. The Vienna Regional Court for Civil Matters found that the controllers violated their information obligations under Article 13(2)(f) GDPR and Article 14(2) GDPR since they failed to inform the data subject about the fact that they are subject to automated decision-making, the court also found a violation of the data subject's right to an explanation under Article 15(1)(h) GDPR and awarded damages under Article 82(1) GDPR in the amount of €1,500. The controllers appealed the judgment to the Vienna Higher Regional Court. The court dismissed the controllers' appeals. Credit rating as an automated decision within the meaning of Article 22(1) GDPR The court analysed the objection to the finding that the generation of the credit rating constituted an automated decision within the meaning of Article 22(1) GDPR. KSV argued that the legal or significant adverse effect on the data subject was not present, and that the latter was only minimally affected by the energy provider's refusal to conclude the contract since he concluded the desired contract with a different provider and subsequently rejected the energy provider’s offer for the contract after their case-by-case review. Thus, KSV claimed that Article 22 GDPR was not applicable and the subsequent information obligations could not have been violated either. However, the court referred to the SCHUFA II case (C-634/21) and showed that the credit rating in this case fell under the application of Article 22 GDPR, since it was a decision based solely on automated processing including profiling which produced legal effects or significantly affected the data subject in a similar manner. It further emphasised that following the CJEU’s decision in the SCHUFA II case, it is generally prohibited to calculate a probability score which plays a decisive role in the granting of a loan to the data subject pursuant to Article 22(1) GDPR. Thus, the court stated that credit rating is only currently permitted on the basis of explicit consent. Moreover, the court concluded that the credit rating calculated by KSV was also the cause of the energy provider’s refusal to enter into a contract with the data subject, causing the latter distress. Therefore, the court held that KSV is liable to the data subject for the damage. In addition, the court considered that the lack of knowledge invoked by KSV was irrelevant in regard to the energy provider’s refusal to enter into a contract with the data subject, since the credit rating was a decision within the meaning of Article 22(1) GDPR regardless if the third party, in this case the energy provider, makes a subsequent decision based on the credit rating. KSV should have anticipated, according to the court, that the credit rating would be used in the context of an automated decision. The court established that it was irrelevant to its liability under Article 82 GDPR whether the controller breached information obligations under Article 14(2) GDPR and 15(1)(h) GDPR, since the data subject did not base his claim for damages on these claims. Instead, the data subject argued that the refusal on behalf of Go Green Energy, based on the creditworthiness scores calculated by KSV, caused him anxiety, annoyance and stress, thus resulting in non-pecuniary damage. Therefore, the court dismissed this part of the appeal by KSV. Exception under Article 22(2) GDPR In addition, the appellate court discussed the exception under Article 22(2)(a) GDPR. While it accepted that the energy provider’s personal data processing can fall within the exception (i.e. it might be necessary for entering into, or performance of, a contract), the court also upheld the conclusion that such automated decision was not permissible in the end. The court stressed the importance of Article 22(3) GDPR in such situations and explained that the data subject must not only be aware of the existence of an automated decision, but also of at least the reasons for the decisions affecting them and its implications. On the basis of this, the court showed, the data subject must be able to determine the accuracy of the information involved in the decision or whether specific circumstances had not been taken into consideration, in order to be able to challenge the decisions if needed. The court pointed out that the controller has the obligation to establish an appropriate process to enable the data subject to exercise these rights. However, the court held that the energy provider could not be presumed to have met these requirements in this case based on the established facts, thus being in breach of Article 22(3) GDPR and subsequently also of Article 22(1) GDPR. Finally, the court dismissed the objections requesting a lower compensation for immaterial damages. Therefore, the court dismissed the appeal of both controllers and upheld the first court’s decision.

Outcome
pending

Decision

OLG Wien judgment12R83/25a of30March2026 dismisses both defendants' appeals against LGZ Wien60Cg82/24f-26 of12August2025 and confirms EUR1,500 GDPR non-pecuniary damages. KSV1870 Information GmbH and go green energy GmbH & Co KG are jointly and severally liable; this is one obligation, not EUR1,500 per company. The court additionally orders joint and several payment of EUR964.82 appeal-response costs to claimant Verein für Konsumenteninformation, including EUR160.80 VAT already within that total. The claimant holds the consumer's assigned claim. Ordinary revision is expressly admissible; finality and actual payment are not independently verified, so pending replaces the unsupported final label. No separate amount is inferred for unspecified interest or first-instance costs. EUR4,500 procedural Streitwert and EUR750 from a cited precedent are not awards in this case. These are civil damages and litigation costs, not an administrative fine or a new award on DPA record4728.

Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for KSV1870 Information GmbH in AT

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

Details

Ruling Date

30 March 2026

Authority

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. KSV1870 Information GmbH - Austria (2026). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: