Infobel
Privacy enforcement record
This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.
The Markets Court upheld Infobel's unlawful-processing finding but replaced the EUR 40,000 fine with EUR 5,000 and annulled two corrective orders. Infobel also bears a EUR 400 appeal fee and an unquantified legal-aid fund contribution. Distinct costs from the earlier procedural appeal are recorded separately.
Payment details and attribution
fine reference amount
annulled · shared reference€40,000
Attribution and source
Reference only; excluded from all totals.
Recorded EUR value: €40,000
View sourcecosts reference amount
imposedla contribution visée à l'article 4, §2 de la loi du 19 mars 2017 instituant un fonds budgétaire relatif à l'aide juridique de deuxième ligne
Source statement; a fixed currency amount has not been established.
fine
imposed · shared reference€5,000
Attribution and source
Shared reference; this obligation is attributed to another case and is not added to this case’s totals.
Recorded EUR value: €5,000
View sourcecosts
imposed€400
Attribution and source
Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.
Recorded EUR value: €400
View sourcecosts
imposed€26
Attribution and source
Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.
Recorded EUR value: €26
View sourcecosts
imposed€1,883.72
Attribution and source
Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.
Recorded EUR value: €1,883.72
View sourcecosts
imposed€400
Attribution and source
Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.
Recorded EUR value: €400
View sourceRecorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.
Jurisdiction and applicable law
- Enforcing jurisdiction
- Belgium · Geography does not establish applicable law.
- Confirmed applicable legislation
- Privacy topics
What happened
A data broker resold telecom-sourced personal data for direct marketing while relying on alleged historic consent and contractual assurances rather than demonstrating valid consent for its own processing.
Who was affected
Infobel SA, enterprise 0453.604.761, was the controller and appellant. The APD defended its decision; the complainant and the redacted telecom intervenor were not liable for the fine or the costs imposed on Infobel.
What the authority found
The unlawful-processing finding survived appeal. The court substituted one EUR 5,000 fine and annulled the erasure and recipient-notification orders. Fixed costs from the two distinct appeals total EUR 2,709.72, plus a later fund contribution whose amount was not stated.
Why this matters
The original and reduced fine are stages of the same sanction and must not both count. Actual costs from separate appeals differ from requested indemnities, calculation inputs and an unquantified contribution.
View original scraped data
Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.
Source checks
Secondary-source text retrieved.
Review needed — 23 June 2026.
Processing notes: amount discrepancy, authority corrected.
Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources
The Markets Court upheld Infobel's unlawful-processing finding but replaced the EUR 40,000 fine with EUR 5,000 and annulled two corrective orders. Infobel also bears a EUR 400 appeal fee and an unquantified legal-aid fund contribution. Distinct costs from the earlier procedural appeal are recorded separately.
Outcome
Decision
This record represents the partially successful merits appeal of 3 June 2026 and also links the separately identified costs of the earlier procedural appeal. The complete official financial chain was reviewed: APD decision 199/2025 of 27 November 2025, DOS-2025-01687 (35 pages, 97,204 extracted characters, including the omitted final operative page read directly); Markets Court judgment 2025/AR/2079 of 3 June 2026 (27 pages, 68,371 characters of locally recognised text, all pages screened and operative pages 25-26 read directly); and the earlier procedural-split appeal 2025/AR/897 of 26 November 2025 (10 pages, 19,987 recognised characters, operative page 10 read directly). The French authority original was read in full; its Dutch translation was acquired and only the annotated identity page and final appeal page were directly read, not the complete translation. Infobel SA, enterprise 0453.604.761, is the controller and payer; the APD is the supervisory authority and court respondent. The case concerns resale of telecom-sourced personal data for direct marketing without demonstrated valid consent. Infobel could not rely simply on contracts or assurances from the original telecom provider. The authority found breaches of Articles 5(1)(a), 6(1) and 24 GDPR, but no Article 17 infringement. The court upheld the unlawful-processing finding and rejected challenges to competence, defence rights, composition, the split procedure and limitation. It did not impose separate fines for each provision. It annulled the erasure and recipient-notification orders because the relevant database had already been deleted in 2023 and the general order exceeded the permissible scope. This was not a finding that the processing had been lawful. The court also annulled the original EUR 40,000 fine and, exercising full jurisdiction, substituted one EUR 5,000 fine. The original fine is a historical annulled reference, not an additional current fine. The court considered gravity low rather than medium, noting insufficient proof of the asserted scale, the improper reliance on pre-GDPR duration, no prior violation or complaint, cooperation and a single complaint. The authority's calculation inputs, EUR 45,000 starting amount, EUR 35,000 intermediate figure, EUR 10,000 reduction, EUR 5,000 adjustment and EUR 9,000 requested alternative are not separate payment obligations. Turnover, statutory ceilings and hypothetical amounts are not awards. In the 2026 appeal each party bears its own costs, with the EUR 400 appeal roll fee and a legal-aid budget fund contribution charged to Infobel. The contribution is imposed but not quantified in the judgment and remains an unquantified EUR reference; the EUR 26 rate in the earlier appeal was not assumed to apply. The APD's EUR 1,883.72 procedural-indemnity request in the 2026 appeal was not awarded. In the distinct 2025 procedural appeal, dismissed as premature/inadmissible, Infobel was ordered to bear EUR 26 budget-fund contribution plus EUR 1,883.72 procedural indemnity in the APD's costs and separately EUR 400 roll fee to SPF Finances. Those three prior costs total EUR 2,309.72; together with the later EUR 400 fee, the fixed costs recorded across both appeals total EUR 2,709.72. No aggregate amount was added on top of these components. The intervenor received no indemnity in the earlier appeal. The later named judgment identifies Infobel as the appellant in the exact earlier docket; masked names were not independently guessed. The French authority narrative refers to decision 77/2025, whereas both court judgments refer to 76/2025 for the split-related proceeding; this source discrepancy is preserved and does not create a second fine. All three public Infobel records are linked to the same reviewed obligations: the sole EUR 5,000 fine counts on record 18291, fixed costs count on court record 18026, and the original EUR 40,000 on 11225 is excluded. Existing raw historic amounts and both merged import aliases remain intact. Exact docket and party follow-up searches located no actual subsequent cassation outcome; no payment, refund, interest, damages or further penalty was inferred and no exchange rate was calculated.
Related Cases (2)
Other cases involving Infobel in BE
Court Ruling
€5K — shared obligation · +4 more payments
Details
Ruling Date
3 June 2026
Authority
Autorité de Protection des Données
Fine Amount
€5,000 — shared obligation
GDPRhub ID
gdprhub-court-10076About this data
Cite as: Cookie Fines. Infobel - Belgium (2026). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu
Last updated: