Court case V ZB 90/25
Privacy enforcement record
This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.
The BGH granted a prospective bidder access to the specified parts of a forced-auction file without redacting personal data. Access remains limited to the statutory documents and does not permit public dissemination or unrelated reuse. The court expressly made no costs order in this decision.
Jurisdiction and applicable law
- Enforcing jurisdiction
- Germany · Geography does not establish applicable law.
- Confirmed applicable legislation
- Privacy topics
What happened
A prospective bidder challenged the requirement to redact personal data before allowing access to specified documents in a Bamberg forced-auction file.
Who was affected
The applicant was an unnamed prospective bidder and third party to the auction. The relevant file was held by the Bamberg enforcement court; the ruling does not identify a company fined for a privacy violation.
What the authority found
The BGH allowed the appeal, quashed the regional-court decision and granted unredacted access under section 42 ZVG. It held the defined access compatible with Article 6(1)(e) GDPR and expressly declined a costs order.
Why this matters
Lawful inspection of specified court documents differs from unrestricted public disclosure. A later fee-calculation value located in a reproduction must not be recorded as an awarded payment; the official follow-up remains to be verified.
View original scraped data
Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.
Source checks
Secondary-source text retrieved.
Automated check recorded — 26 June 2026.
Processing notes: articles corrected, authority corrected.
Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources
The BGH granted a prospective bidder access to the specified parts of a forced-auction file without redacting personal data. Access remains limited to the statutory documents and does not permit public dissemination or unrelated reuse. The court expressly made no costs order in this decision.
Outcome
Decision
The complete official 22-page BGH decision V ZB 90/25 of 21 May 2026, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:210526BVZB90.25.0, was read (42,060 extracted characters), all pages screened and operative page 2 plus costs page 22 read directly. A prospective bidder, an unnamed third-party applicant rather than a party to the property auction, sought access to the statutory parts of the Bamberg forced-auction file. The BGH allowed her appeal, quashed LG Bamberg's decision of 24 November 2025, 32 T 80/25 e, and amended AG Bamberg's decision of 3 November 2025, 2 K 43/24, to grant access without redaction. It decided the access issue itself; it did not remit the merits. Section 42 ZVG permits anyone to inspect the specified land-register communications, applications and property evidence, including the valuation report, without having names, birth dates, addresses or deleted land-register entries blacked out. This does not extend the statutory right to every part of the auction file: other material remains subject to the requirements of section 299(2) ZPO. The GDPR applies to court file access, including paper filing systems, and the court held the specified access lawful under Article 6(1)(e), with section 42 ZVG providing the national basis and with proportionality and data minimisation satisfied by the defined scope and procedural purpose. The interest in achieving a value-appropriate realisation of the property was balanced against the data subjects' interests. This is not an unrestricted right to publish personal data: sections 299(4), sentence 2 and 869 ZPO prohibit public dissemination or making the accessed material available to third parties for purposes unrelated to the proceedings. The BGH declined a CJEU referral because the relevant EU-law standards were sufficiently clear. The complete May decision imposes no fine, damages, restitution, settlement sum or coercive payment. It expressly makes no costs order because the third-party applicant and the auction participants do not face each other as opposing parties in adversarial civil proceedings. This does not establish that all underlying proceedings or private legal representation were free. Property values, creditor satisfaction and possible sale proceeds are explanatory background, not sums awarded in this file-access decision. An actual subsequent decision of 20 July 2026 in the same docket, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:200726BVZB90.25.0, was located. A complete 10,290-character third-party reproduction was read for the follow-up inquiry; it describes a EUR 1,000 value for calculating counsel's remuneration and states that court fees were not charged because the appeal succeeded. A calculation value is not a EUR 1,000 fee award or damages payment and no sum was imported from that reproduction. Its official NeuRIS API link returned HTTP 410, the official legacy PDF connection failed and the current portal navigation timed out. The official July decision, the 2 July 2026 transfer decision mentioned in the reproduction and the full lower decisions have not been obtained. This record therefore remains on an evidence hold for the complete official financial chain, while the May source's disposition is fully read. No named company, fee payer, actual lawyer invoice, payment, refund or currency conversion was invented.
Related Cases (0)
No other cases found for Court case V ZB 90/25 in DE
This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.
Details
About this data
Cite as: Cookie Fines. Court case V ZB 90/25 - Germany (2026). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu
Last updated: