Data Subject versus Regional Public Broadcasting Authority – Court Ruling (Germany, 2026)

The data subject had been liable to pay broadcasting contributions to the Controller, a German regional public broadcasting authority, since 2007. Following objections to several contribution assessment notices, the data subject submitted a request under Article 15 GDPR seeking a copy of all personal data processed about him by the Controller. The Controller responded by providing the categories of personal data and related information specified under § 11(8) of the German Broadcasting Contribution Treaty (RBStV), which governs data subject access requests relating to broadcasting contribution records, together with general privacy information. The data subject argued that the response was incomplete because it did not include copies of all documents containing his personal data, including correspondence with him and third parties. The Controller maintained that it had fully complied with its obligations under the RBStV. After the Controller declined to provide additional information, the data subject brought proceedings seeking disclosure of all personal data concerning him processed by the Controller. The Court held that § 11(8) of the German Broadcasting Contribution Treaty (RBStV) constituted a lawful restriction of the broader right of access under Article 15 GDPR pursuant to Article 23(1)(e) GDPR. It found that the national provision was a valid legislative measure, respected the essence of the fundamental right to data protection, and pursued an important public interest by ensuring the effective financing and administration of the public broadcasting system. The Court further held that the restriction was necessary and proportionate, noting that requiring the Controller to comply with the full scope of Article 15 GDPR across more than 44 million broadcasting contribution accounts would impose a disproportionate administrative and financial burden capable of undermining that public interest. The Court also held that § 11(8) RBStV satisfied the safeguards r