DPA case 72/2023

Dismissed
Autorité de Protection des Données12 June 2023Belgium
final
Dismissed

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

The Belgian authority closed a complaint seeking return of an entire litigation file from a court-appointed liquidator. It treated this as a professional and liquidation dispute rather than a GDPR access request. A separate personal-data access right may still exist. No fine or compensation was imposed.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
Belgium · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation
No confirmed legal basis recorded.
Privacy topics

What happened

A woman requested her legal files from her new lawyer but did not receive them.

Who was affected

The woman who sought her legal files and her new lawyer.

What the authority found

The authority ruled that it lacked the competence to address the complaint since it was not based on GDPR.

Why this matters

This case shows that not all legal issues fall under data protection laws, highlighting the need for clarity on the authority's scope.

Source checks

Linked-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 18 October 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

In the context of a legal proceedings, a data subject was attributed a new lawyer after the death of her previous one. She then requested from her new lawyer to return her the legal files but he didn't, claiming that he hadn't had the time to go through all the files of the deceased lawyer yet. The data subject contacted the bar association to intervene but it concluded that it could not issue any injunctions to the lawyer. She therefore filed a complaint with the Belgian DPA The Belgian DPA stated that the data subject did not complain on the basis on the GDPR. The DPA referred the EDPB Guidelines 01/2022 on data subject rights - right of access, where it is stated that "if the data subjects clarify that their request is based on sectoral legislation or on national legislation regulating the specific issue of access to certain categories of data, and not on the GDPR, such a request shall be examined by the controller in accordance with such sectoral or national rules, where applicable". The DPA considered that it is clear from the facts that this matter concerned lawyers professional conduct and that it had, in any case, no competence to order the restitution of the file. The DPA added that the right of access under Article 15 would unlikely result in the retrieval of the file, it would only grant access to the communication of the personal data relating to the data subject.

Outcome

Decision

Belgian decision 72/2023 of 12 June 2023 (DOS-2023-01513) technically closes a complaint seeking return of an entire litigation file from a lawyer acting as court-appointed liquidator of a deceased lawyer's practice. The complaint and correspondence concerned professional duties and liquidation, not exercise of a GDPR data right. Data subjects need not cite the GDPR for a valid access request; the authority's conclusion is specific to the substance of these requests. It had no power to order return or transfer of the entire litigation file or to supervise the liquidator's mandate. A separate Article 15 request could cover the complainant's personal data without necessarily returning the entire file. The authority adds that even a hypothetical access complaint would face discretionary closure because it was ancillary to the wider file-return dispute, with bar disciplinary proceedings pending and liquidation supervision for the competent court. The decision does not resolve those proceedings or prove that the lawyer fulfilled all professional duties. It imposes no return order, costs or compensation; 'restitution' here means documents, not money. Exact-dossier searches identified the primary decision only, not an actual further decision or judicial appeal. No fine, damages, costs, settlement or other monetary award is imposed. Standard appeal instructions do not establish an actual appeal.

Related Enforcement Actions (0)

No other enforcement actions found for DPA case 72/2023 in BE

This is the only recorded action for this entity in this jurisdiction.

Details

Decision Date

12 June 2023

Authority

Autorité de Protection des Données

GDPRhub ID

gdprhub-6040

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. DPA case 72/2023 - Belgium (2023). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: