Court case W245 2250950-1

€1.3K — costsDatenschutzbehörde12 October 2023Austria
pending
Court Ruling

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

The Austrian Administrative Court set aside an earlier confidentiality judgment because the required hearing had not been held. It ordered the state to reimburse the appellant association EUR 1,346.40 in costs. The subsequent outcome is unverified.

Payment details and attribution

costs

imposed

€1,346.40

Attribution and source

Included in this case’s attributed EUR totals.

Recorded EUR value: €1,346.40

View source

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
Austria · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation

What happened

An association appealed a confidentiality finding concerning disclosure of personal data. The court’s earlier rejection of its appeal was later set aside.

Who was affected

The individual whose personal data was shared without consent.

What the authority found

The higher court set aside the earlier judgment due to a procedural defect; the outcome following that decision is not independently verified.

Why this matters

The decision concerns the need for a hearing where relevant facts remain disputed.

Recorded legal citations
Automatically processed
Art. 4 GDPR
Art. 5 GDPR
Art. 6 GDPR
View original scraped data
Art. 4(GDPR)
Art. 5(GDPR)
Art. 6(GDPR)

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

National Law Articles
AI-identified
§ 1 DSG
Article 133(4) B-VG
Decision AuthorityBVwG
Reviewed AuthorityDSB (Austria)

Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 13 July 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, national law identified, authority corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

On 28.11.2019, the data subject received their regional government's administrative decision regarding the recognition of previous qualifications and their experience in becoming a mountain sports guide. On 12.02.2020, the controller attempted to challenge the decision and sent an email to further recipients besides the affected authority. They expressed their concerns and included unredacted parts of the administrative decision. On 18.12.2020. the data subject lodged a complaint with the Austrian DPA (DSB) regarding the violation of their right to confidentiality under [https://ris.bka.gv.at/eli/bgbl/i/1999/165/A1P1/NOR40139563?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=DSG&Gesetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=1&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=13.07.2026&VonInkrafttretedatum=&BisInkrafttretedatum=&VonAusserkrafttretedatum=&BisAusserkrafttretedatum=&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=b2435486-6818-41ec-a0f8-4150a50eb221 §1(1) DSG]. On 09.12.2021, the DPA partly confirmed the data subject's complaint, stating that the the email contained personal data of the data subject under Article 4(1) GDPR. The controller subsequently appealed against the DPA's decision on 05.01.2022, arguing that their actions were justified by legitimate interests in safeguarding professional standards and public safety pursuant to Article 6(1)(f) GDPR. Furthermore, only parts of the administrative decision were cited, thereby adhering to the principle of data minimisation under Article 5(1)(c) GDPR. First, the court held that the data subject had neither consented to the processing of their personal data nor was the processing in their vital interest under [https://ris.bka.gv.at/eli/bgbl/i/1999/165/A1P1/NOR40139563?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=DSG&Gesetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=1&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=13.07.2026&VonInkrafttretedatum=&BisInkrafttretedatum=&VonAusserkrafttretedatum=&BisAusserkrafttretedatum=&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=b2435486-6818-41ec-a0f8-4150a50eb221 §1(2) DSG]. Second, the controller had the obligation to determine the purpose of the data processing (see 12.02.2020) before executing it rather than throughout the proceedings under Article 5(1)(b) GDPR. The subsequent supplemental citation of the purpose is not reconcilable with the principle of good faith (Article 5(1)(a) GDPR). Third, the court stated that, in reference to the CJEU's decision in [https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:62021CJ0252 'Meta Platforms and Others' (C-252/21) ECLI:EU:C:2023:537], the burden of proof lies with the controller to demonstrate in a for the data subject understandable way that the data processing was legal, legitimate and necessary under Article 5(2) GDPR. Fourth, the court held that the supplemental citation of the purpose did not justify the processing of the data subject's personal data, since sending a warning to certain recipients with the affected data redacted was feasible. Therefore, the processing was not necessary under Article 6(1)(e) GDPR and Article 6(1)(f) GDPR. Hence, the court dismissed the appeal as unfounded. Fifth, the court held that no appeal to the Austrian Supreme Administrative Court (Verwaltungsgerichtshof) was admissible pursuant to [https://ris.bka.gv.at/eli/bgbl/1930/1/A133/NOR40201324?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Kundmachungsorgan=&Index=&Titel=B-VG&Gesetzesnummer=&VonArtikel=133&BisArtikel=&VonParagraf=&BisParagraf=&VonAnlage=&BisAnlage=&Typ=&Kundmachungsnummer=&Unterzeichnungsdatum=&FassungVom=13.07.2026&VonInkrafttretedatum=&BisInkrafttretedatum=&VonAusserkrafttretedatum=&BisAusserkrafttretedatum=&NormabschnittnummerKombination=Und&ImRisSeitVonDatum=&ImRisSeitBisDatum=&ImRisSeit=Undefined&ResultPageSize=100&Suchworte=&Position=1&SkipToDocumentPage=true&ResultFunctionToken=4c0c3096-fcc5-4494-8001-860e8840f341 Article 133(4) B-VG], as the case was primarily centred on questions of fact, and no legal questions of fundamental importance were raised. The decision was also entirely aligned with established case law.

Outcome
pending

Decision

On 25 November 2025, the Austrian Administrative Court set aside judgment W245 2250950-1 because of a procedural defect. It ordered the Austrian state to reimburse the appellant association EUR 1,346.40 in costs; this is not a fine against the association. Any subsequent decision and actual payment remain unverified.

Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Court case W245 2250950-1 in AT

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

Details

Ruling Date

12 October 2023

Authority

Datenschutzbehörde

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. Court case W245 2250950-1 - Austria (2023). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: