Ministry of Justice

GBP 2.3K — damages · +1 more paymentsDPA EWHC11 June 2014United Kingdom
final
Court Ruling

Court ruling predating the GDPR

This national court ruling predates the GDPR. Consult the recorded legal bases and decision for its applicable law. It is excluded from cookie statistics and the Risk Calculator.

The High Court awarded a claimant £2,251 in damages against the Ministry of Justice over delays in responding to personal data requests.

Payment details and attribution

damages

imposed

GBP 2,250

EUR conversion unavailable

Attribution and source

Attributed to this case in its original currency; not included in EUR totals without an evidenced conversion.

View source

damages

imposed

GBP 1

EUR conversion unavailable

Attribution and source

Attributed to this case in its original currency; not included in EUR totals without an evidenced conversion.

View source

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
United Kingdom · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation
No confirmed legal basis recorded.
Privacy topics

What happened

The Ministry of Justice did not respond to multiple requests for personal data within the required time frame.

Who was affected

A man seeking personal data related to his wife's inquest from the Ministry of Justice.

What the authority found

The award comprised £1 in nominal damages and £2,250 for distress; the claimant is anonymised as AB.

Why this matters

This ruling reinforces the importance of timely responses to data requests. Businesses must ensure they have processes in place to handle such requests efficiently to avoid legal issues.

National Law Articles
AI-identified
DPA 1998 s.7, s.13
Decision AuthorityEWHC (UK)

Source checks

Linked-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 21 March 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected, national law identified, authority corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

The data subject made multiple subject access requests (SARs) to the Ministry of Justice following his wife's death, seeking personal data concerning communications between officials about the inquest. The first relevant SAR was made on 22 October 2006. The data subject made further requests on 19 December 2006, 21 April 2007, and 12 September 2007. The data controller failed to respond within the statutory 40-day period under section 7(8) DPA 1998. Material was eventually disclosed approximately 17 months after the relevant request, in March 2009. Some material was withheld for over 6 years on grounds of legal professional privilege, though the court later found one annotated document should have been disclosed as privilege had been waived when shown to a non-lawyer for independent opinion. The data subject sought damages for breach of statutory duty, distress caused by the delays, and time/costs incurred pursuing the requests. The High Court held that the controller breached section 7(8) DPA 1998 by failing to respond to the data subject's SAR within the prescribed 40-day period. On damages, the court held: First, the data subject was entitled to nominal damages of GBP 1 for the breach, as he failed to properly quantify his professional time and expenses. Second, critically, the court held that once "damage" (even nominal) was established under section 13(1), the data subject became entitled to compensation for distress under section 13(2). The court stated: "By accepting that the claimant suffered some damage... even if only to the extent of a nominal sum, it follows that the claimant has satisfied the requirements of section 13(2)(a), which means that an individual who has also suffered relevant distress is entitled to an award of compensation in respect of it." Third, the court awarded £2,250 for distress caused specifically by the delays in responding to the SARs, stating this represented "fair and proportionate compensation for the distress." On the withheld material, the court found most was properly protected by legal professional privilege, but one annotated document had lost privilege protection when shown to a non-lawyer for independent opinion.

Outcome

Decision

In AB v Ministry of Justice [2014] EWHC 1847 (QB), the High Court awarded the claimant nominal damages of GBP 1 and GBP 2,250 for distress arising from delays in access to personal data. Costs were left for agreement or further submissions. No euro conversion is applied without an evidenced rate. Any appeal, later costs order and actual payment remain unverified.

Details

Ruling Date

11 June 2014

Authority

DPA EWHC

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. Ministry of Justice - United Kingdom (2014). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: