SPF Justice / Direction du Moniteur belge

€20 — costs, reference only, shared obligation · +1 more paymentsCourt of Justice of the European Union11 January 2024European Union
final
CJEU Judgment

CJEU judgment — not a DPA enforcement action

This is a Court of Justice ruling, not an enforcement action by a data protection authority. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

The Belgian court entirely annulled the 2021 reprimand and erasure order on 16 April 2025. The privacy authority must reimburse the Belgian State €20 and €1,883.72 in appeal costs. These shared procedural costs are excluded from GDPR fine totals.

Payment details and attribution

costs reference amount

imposed · shared reference

€20

Attribution and source

Reference only; excluded from all totals.

Recorded EUR value: €20

View source

costs reference amount

imposed · shared reference

€1,883.72

Attribution and source

Reference only; excluded from all totals.

Recorded EUR value: €1,883.72

View source

Recorded obligations, not money collected. Shared obligations count once; payment types stay separate.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
European Union · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation
Privacy topics

What happened

The original reprimand and erasure order concerning a corporate publication were entirely annulled on 16 April 2025.

Who was affected

The shareholder complainant LM was affected by publication of personal data. SPF Justice / Moniteur belge was the respondent controller; the APD must pay the appeal costs.

What the authority found

CJEU C-231/22 clarified controller responsibility without deciding erasure. The Market Court retained controller status but annulled APD decision 38/2021 because it inadequately addressed the statutory duty to publish the notarial extract unchanged.

Why this matters

Controller status alone did not resolve the erasure dispute. The later national annulment and the APD's two procedural cost obligations must be distinguished from GDPR enforcement fines.

Recorded legal citations
Automatically processed
Art. 4(7) GDPR
Art. 5(2) GDPR
Art. 17(1) GDPR
Art. 26(1) GDPR
View original scraped data
Art. 4(7) GDPR
Art. 5(2) GDPR
Art. 17(1) GDPR
Art. 26(1) GDPR

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

Decision AuthorityCJEU

Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 19 March 2026.

No issues were reported by that automated check.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

A notary mistakenly included shareholders' names, bank accounts and capital repayments in a corporate publication. APD decision 38/2021 reprimanded SPF Justice / Moniteur belge and ordered erasure. Following the 2022 preliminary reference and CJEU judgment C-231/22, the Market Court entirely annulled the APD decision on 16 April 2025. The APD must reimburse the Belgian State EUR20 and EUR1883.72 in procedural costs; these are not fines or damages against the controller or shareholder.

Outcome

Decision

Full official APD decision38/2021 (23March2021; DOS-2020-00404), Market Court23February2022 and16April2025 (2021/AR/657), and CJEU11January2024 (C231/22; EU:C:2024:7) reviewed. The respondent/controller is SPF Justice, Direction du Moniteur belge, not the shareholder complainant LM. The2021APD reprimand and erasure/reporting order within30days of notification were ENTIRELY ANNULLED by the Market Court on16April2025. The court retained controller status but held the APD decision inadequately addressed the statutory duty to publish the notarial extract unchanged; a legislative gap required a legislative solution. Removal of the original onlinePDF and a rectified publication satisfied the parties in practice, but did not extinguish their interest in annulment and were not declared lawful amendments of the statutory publication rules. The2022court and2024CJEU judgments reserved national costs; neither imposed a fine. The2025court orders APD to reimburse the Belgian State EUR20 budget-fund contribution PLUS EUR1883.72 procedural indemnity; these two shared reference cost components are linked once to4346 and6660 and excluded from controller enforcement totals. APD is exempt from the separate appeal registration fee. The voluntary intervening complainant bears own costs without an adverse indemnity. Earlier EUR1560/EUR1800 indemnity requests were not awarded. The requested daily astreinte was not imposed. Capital repayments in the underlying publication were corporate distributions, not GDPR compensation. The European judgment addresses controller responsibility and does not itself grant erasure or reverse the later national annulment. No later cassation judgment was located in the followup search; no actual payment or further finality inferred.

Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for SPF Justice / Direction du Moniteur belge in EU

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

Details

Judgment Date

11 January 2024

Authority

Court of Justice of the European Union

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. SPF Justice / Direction du Moniteur belge - European Union (2024). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: