Court case VI ZR 375/24

Court Ruling
DPA BGH12 May 2026Germany
final
Court Ruling

Privacy enforcement record

This record is classified outside cookie consent. Subject classification does not confirm an applicable law. It is not included in cookie statistics or the Risk Calculator.

The BGH upheld the order requiring an unnamed debt collector to withdraw unlawful SCHUFA reports. It found the lower court had wrongly denied non-material damage and remitted damages and costs for a new decision. It did not fix a compensation amount.

Jurisdiction and applicable law
Enforcing jurisdiction
Germany · Geography does not establish applicable law.
Confirmed applicable legislation
Privacy topics

What happened

An unnamed debt collector reported a disputed energy-supply debt to SCHUFA. The data subject sought withdrawal of the reports and compensation for non-material damage.

Who was affected

The defendant was the reporting debt collection company. The claimant was the affected individual; SCHUFA received the reports and was not the defendant in this action.

What the authority found

Withdrawal of the unlawful reports survived revision. The BGH recognised damage on the established facts, quashed the adverse damages and costs parts of the appeal judgment and remitted those issues without fixing a new amount.

Why this matters

Damage need not reach a seriousness threshold or stem solely from one unlawful report. The historic EUR 500 trial award and the disputed debt balances must not be recorded as a final compensation award after remittal.

Recorded legal citations
Automatically processed
Art. 19 GDPR
Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR
Art. 82 GDPR
Art. 17(1)(d) GDPR
View original scraped data
Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR
Art. 17(1)(d) GDPR
Art. 19(GDPR)
Art. 82(GDPR)

Original imported citations before automated processing; the processing history does not establish independent verification.

Decision AuthorityBGH

Source checks

Secondary-source text retrieved.

Automated check recorded — 8 July 2026.

Processing notes: articles corrected.

Retrieved text may be a secondary summary or an announcement. These automated statuses do not establish that the original decision was read or that the record received an independent legal review. How we check sources

Full Legal Summary
Detailed

The BGH upheld the order requiring an unnamed debt collector to withdraw unlawful SCHUFA reports. It found the lower court had wrongly denied non-material damage and remitted damages and costs for a new decision. It did not fix a compensation amount.

Outcome

Decision

This record represents the BGH revision judgment and its remittal on damages and costs. The complete official BGH judgment VI ZR 375/24 of 12 May 2026, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:120526UVIZR375.24.0, was reviewed: 24 pages and 43,798 extracted characters, with all pages screened and operative pages 2 and 23 plus financial-history page 3 read directly. It expressly identifies the linked earlier decisions as LG Kiel, 9 January 2024, 17 O 130/23, and OLG Schleswig, 22 November 2024, 17 U 2/24, as corrected on 17 December 2024. The defendant is an unnamed debt collection company that reported the alleged debt to SCHUFA; SCHUFA is the recipient, not the defendant in this action. The underlying energy supplier and other debts are background. The BGH dismissed the debt collector's revision, leaving the order to withdraw the two unlawful SCHUFA reports intact. The reports concerned a disputed, untitled debt that had not even been plausibly substantiated in its entirety, so they were not suitable to support an objective and reliable assessment of creditworthiness and were not necessary under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR. This was a GDPR analysis; section 31 BDSG does not directly govern transmission to a credit bureau. The BGH did not decide that every conceivable credit report is unlawful or determine the underlying energy debt. It left open whether the withdrawal remedy arises directly from Articles 17 and 19 GDPR, because an appropriate national-law remedy would in any event be permissible. The claimant's cross-revision succeeded. The BGH quashed the appeal judgment on costs and insofar as it was adverse to the claimant, remitting those issues, including revision costs, to the appellate court. It held that actual damage to economic reputation was established on the unchallenged findings that these reports adversely affected the score and that potential contracting partners had considered that score. There is no seriousness threshold; it was not necessary to show that these reports alone or predominantly caused the poor score or failed contracts. Their relative effect may matter to quantum. The court also rejected the lower court's reasons for denying loss-of-control damage: the data and affected score were available to, and had been queried by, other potential contracting parties. Proof of helplessness, surveillance or special anxiety was not required on these facts. It did not decide a purely consequence-free hypothetical loss-of-control case. Withdrawal of the reports is not itself full compensation for damage already suffered. The BGH did not quantify or newly award damages. Its history records a EUR 500 first-instance damages award plus pre-litigation legal costs, followed by the appeal court's rejection of damages. Those historical EUR 500 were not automatically reinstated as a final payment by the BGH's remittal. The pre-litigation costs are mentioned as awarded below, but their amount, interest and complete operative terms have not been obtained; they are unresolved, not certified absent. The energy invoice of EUR 529.16, reported balances of EUR 795 and EUR 817, instalments and alleged delay charges are not privacy damages, fines or litigation-cost awards in this judgment. The quashed appeal cost disposition must not be treated as a current final allocation. Remitting revision costs for later decision is not a present award against a verified payer. No fine, settlement or fixed coercive payment is imposed by this BGH judgment. The original lower judgments, the December correction and an actual post-remand decision determining final quantum and costs remain missing. Direct retrieval of the official Schleswig juris page, the official standalone journal decision and the official complete journal failed with TLS or connection errors; no substitute text was declared fully reviewed. Exact-docket follow-up searches located no actual post-remand disposition. Both linked records therefore remain on an evidence hold for the full financial chain. No final damages amount, interest, costs amount, payment, refund, company identity or FX conversion was invented or added.

Related Cases (0)

No other cases found for Court case VI ZR 375/24 in DE

This is the only recorded case for this entity in this jurisdiction.

Details

Ruling Date

12 May 2026

Authority

DPA BGH

About this data

Data: GDPRhub (noyb.eu)
Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Automatically normalized and classified

Cite as: Cookie Fines. Court case VI ZR 375/24 - Germany (2026). Retrieved from cookiefines.eu

Report Inaccuracy

Last updated: